With little more
than a day's notice, 35 residents and business owners in the
Historic
Ybor Neighborhood Civic Association mustered an
emergency meeting last week.
The newspaper
headlines called for action:
A man was fatally
shot over the weekend, minutes after being kicked out of
Empire Nightclub for fighting with the alleged gunman.
Neighbors had
griped about crime surrounding Empire and its nightclub
neighbor Fuel for about a year. They'd even met with Mayor Pam
Iorio last fall to discuss their worries.
"Enough is enough.
We're fed up with what's going on," association president Tony
LaColla said when he found out about the shooting.
"It's hurting
business. It's going against our plan to bring more people to
Ybor."
The neighbors
needed to act fast, they decided. The city needed to get more
involved. Police needed to do more.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Empire Nightclub
and Club Fuel share the 1900 block of E Seventh Avenue. Drink
specials and nonstop hip-hop draw huge crowds on weekend
nights.
Neighbors say they
also draw trouble.
In 2002, two of
Empire's bouncers were shot after telling a man to take off
his knit cap. One died. The gunman got two life sentences.
Last fall, a
Temple Terrace man was stabbed to death in a parking lot
outside Empire, also after an argument.
In 2003, a man was
stabbed on Club Fuel's dance floor and survived. Two years
later, a man was shot outside the club.
That same year,
2,000 teenagers left an "All Ages High School Party" at Club
Fuel and flooded the streets. It took 30 police officers and a
helicopter to keep them under control.
After the most
recent shooting at Empire, Tampa police Lt. Diane Hobley-Burney
said she couldn't comment on the club because the shooting
happened between individuals, outside.
But she did say
that violent crime in Ybor City, including murders and
robberies, is down 15 percent.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Residents don't
question that the police presence in Ybor City is high.
"The perpetrators
have been busted, so it shows police are on top of things,"
LaColla said.
But they have
several concerns. One is that off-duty police officers are
hired and paid privately by clubs to act as security guards.
LaColla wonders if uneven wages among clubs might cause the
guards to favor some establishments over others.
Also, security
guards typically escort people who fight at the clubs off the
property, LaColla said. He wonders if more could be done.
"Maybe they need
to be brought to detox," LaColla said. "Maybe they need to be
brought to jail."
After being
bombarded with e-mails by Ybor residents, City Council
chairwoman Gwendolyn Miller asked police last week to create a
report on how the megaclubs factor into crime in Ybor. The
report is due to the council Thursday.
"We need to kind
of control what's going on, because we are trying to get Ybor
City back to where it should be," Miller said. "And now people
are going to be afraid to go to Ybor City."
Through Tampa
police spokeswoman Laura McElroy, District 3 Cmdr. Maj. Robert
Guidara declined to comment for this story.
"He's
uncomfortable talking about the problem until he has put
together this report to City Council," McElroy said.
Representatives of
Empire and Fuel could not be reached for comment.
But after the
Sunday shooting, Empire owner Ken Grossman told the Times
that people are patted down for weapons when they walk into
his club. There's nothing he can do, he said, to stop problems
that spill into the streets.
Last week,
Grossman met with the neighborhood association president for
the first time. LaColla left feeling optimistic.
"They were willing
to work with us and they said, 'Hey, give us your solutions,
give us your ideas and we'll see what we can do.' At least
Empire is," LaColla said. "Club Fuel - I don't believe they're
interested in dealing with the neighborhood right now."
- - - - - - - - - - - -
The same day
police give their report, Club Fuel chief financial officer
Richard MacKizer will stand trial for the club's allegedly
violating the city's noise code, a criminal offense punishable
by up to 60 days in jail, a $500 fine or six months'
probation.
Club Fuel has been
cited eight times, including at least three warnings, for
pumping its bass too loud, said prosecutor David Shobe. That's
the highest number of noise violations at a club in Ybor City.
Two other Fuel
associates face similar charges for noise violations: Jai
Lalwani and Joseph Azzi, who is no longer with the club. Their
charges were filed after MacKizer's.
If any of them are
found guilty, the City Council would have the chance to review
the club's wet zoning, which is required for alcohol sales,
and possibly suspend or revoke its permits.
Miller says she is
tracking the court cases and won't hesitate to call a hearing.
"I'd be willing to
revoke their license," Miller said. "I'm for the neighbors. I
know how it is when you're in a neighborhood like that."
Miller isn't
stopping with the police, she said.
"I think really
it's a wet-zoning issue. That's drawing them to the clubs, and
I think we need to look into whether they're doing it
correctly. If they're abusing their wet-zoning licenses, we
need to do something about it."
Residents sent a
letter Monday to the mayor, City Council members, the city
attorney's office and all of the city's neighborhood
association presidents pitching their own amendments to the
city wet-zoning code.
The residents want
a "conditional use permit" that would apply to all bars within
500 feet of a residence that have a maximum occupancy of 250
or more.
They want clubs to
require bouncers to attend a training program, to post rules
of conduct prominently outside, and to create plans of action
to deal with fights, drugs, intoxicated patrons, underage
drinking and loitering. If any of these conditions are
violated, a club should lose its wet zoning, the residents
say.
Independently of
Ybor residents, the City Council is reviewing and changing the
wet zoning permitting process. The city attorney's office is
studying the neighborhood's ideas to see if they can apply to
the city's revisions.
Any changes
wouldn't affect Empire or Fuel - they're already grandfathered
into current guidelines. But revisions would apply to any new
club that opens.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
LaColla welcomes
the broader approach.
"We have to do
more than just look at one specific nightclub," he said.
"There's underlying issues that need to be addressed."
Residents continue
their struggle to diversify the types of entertainment in Ybor
City.
"That's really one
of our biggest concerns," LaColla said. Residents want "more
restaurants, retail, more activities for everyone."
Miller agreed:
"You don't need all those clubs."